AT A GLANCE MASSACRE AT BABI YAR
In the years after the Holocaust, many pieces of music have been composed commemorating Holocaust events or experiences. Arnold Schoenberg’s A Survivor from Warsaw, composed in 1947, presents audiences with a fictional representation of the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising. In fact, it contains inaccurate information about the Warsaw ghetto, for example the mention of gas chambers even though none existed in the ghetto. In 1962, the Russian poet Evgeny Evtushenko visited the site of Babi Yar, a deep ravine northwest of Kiev, where in September 1941 an estimated 70,000 Jews were executed by Nazi soldiers. This was one of the largest mass murders at an individual location during World War II (see box below).
Babi Yar is a deep ravine situated to the northwest of Kiev, the capital of the Soviet Ukraine when the Nazis invaded the Soviet Union in June 1941. At that time, 170,000 Jews lived in Kiev, about 20% of the city's population but approximately 100,000 Jews had fled Kiev before the Nazi occupation. Most of those who remained were women, children, the elderly and the sick who had been unable to flee. On September 29-30, 1941, SS and police units and their assistants, under guidance of members of Einsatzgruppe* (mobile killing unit) C, murdered the Jewish population of Kiev at Babi Yar. The Jewish people were assembled, marched to the edge of the ravine and shot. Reports by the Einsatzgruppe to headquarters stated that 33,771 Jews were massacred in two days. In the following months, thousands more Jews were killed at Babi Yar, as well as many non-Jews including Roma (Gypsies), Communists, and Soviet prisoners of war. It is estimated that in total, 100,000 people were murdered at Babi Yar. Kiev was liberated by the Soviet army on November 6, 1943.
Evtushenko returned to his hotel room and immediately wrote a memorial poem in which the first line, which reads: There are no monuments over Babi Yar, the steep precipice, like a rough-hewn tomb reflected his ‘refusal to accept the injustice of history, the absence of a monument to so many innocent slaughtered people’. Not long after this, Shostakovich read the poem and decided to set it as part of a symphonic work that would include five movements, each of them based on an Evtushenko poem. In Different Trains (1988), Steve Reich presents a semi- autobiographical account of the Holocaust that elec- tronically mixes his memories of being a Jewish child in the 1940s with those of child-survivors of the Holocaust who later recorded their testimonies.
Explore LISTENING TO MUSIC CAN BE AN EMOTIONAL EXPERIENCE, ESPECIALLY IF YOU KNOW THE STORY CONNECTED TO IT.   BUT WHAT IF YOU DON'T KNOW THE STORY - DOES THAT MATTER? DO YOU THINK IT IS IMPORTANT THAT A COMPOSER PERSONALLY EXPERIENCED THE EVENTS THEIR MUSIC IS ABOUT?  NO, I THINK AN ARTIST CAN BE MOVED AND INSPIRED BY SOMETHING THEY HAVEN'T EXPERIENCED, AS SHOSTAKOVITCH WAS. YES, AND I THINK REICH'S PIECE IS MOST 'AUTHENTIC' BECAUSE HE ACTUALLY WENT THROUGH SOME OF THOSE THINGS. HMMM… MEMORIAL COMPOSITIONS ARE QUITE CONTROVERSIAL, AREN'T THEY?  WHAT DO YOU THINK? BEFORE THE HOLOCAUST MUSIC AS IDEOLOGY MUSIC AS MENACE MUSIC AS MEMORY MUSIC AS DOCUMENTARY MUSIC AS POWER MUSIC AS RESISTANCE